Are you sure it opens at the top?
That would allow it to flop open virtually all the time, so I just can't see it being that way. My '07 has the hinge pins along the top, allowing the bottom to open when the fan is blowing air. Of course, you want those retainer tabs holding the flap closed during travel and in cold weather.
Get up there on a ladder and check to see if the plastic "pins" at each upper corner aren't broken, which would allow the flap to "FLOP" when undoing those tabs. Mine broke on me and I bought another housing at a parts store, removed the flap and installed it in the OEM housing. Another way to fix is to glue a welding rod along the top of the flap so it serves as a hinge.