Thetford Aria toilet noises

[tricotec]

Originally Posted by RonNBama

tricotec, is the "footprint" of the manual-flush toilet the same as the Aria? Mine came with a spare valve mechanism, but I am considering replacing the entire unit unless the modifications are a challenge.

The Aria Classic is EXACTLY the same toilet with a manual pedal that protrudes from the front of the toilet. If you're stuck with an Aria Deluxe, this is the replacement for you. The mounting bolts and water connection are identical. Just remember that the Aria comes in low and high profile (height from the floor) so you will have to match that and the color.

We replaced ours and it was like night and day. It was actually a pleasure to use the rest room. (I know that seems silly, but anyone who has one of these demon possessed toilets will understand) You will NOT be sorry you replaced it.

I would add that the pedal actuator on the manual version of this toilet is very well designed and is easy to operate. Right in front where it's easily accessible, and not way up on the side where you have to lift your foot way off the ground. Press half-way down to fill, and all the way down to flush...works great. The water also does not pulse on the manual toilet, and the flapper is silent. This is the closest it comes to a real sticks and bricks home toilet. I really, really liked the Aria Classic.

[gruelens]

I purchase my 2007 MH used approx two years ago. The previous owner stated he had replaced the Aria II twice due to failures. He wanted to have a manual toilet, but the DW wanted to push the button. The Aria II became noisy shortly after I purchased the Mountain Aire. I spoke with a repairman that said it is just a matter of time. As a fulltimer I decided to do it on my schedule, not an emergency schedule. Replaced it with a manual china toilet and I am glad I did.

[Robi.1014]

For those who have replaced the Aria Delux "noise maker"....

Is the Camping-World "Aqua Magic" at just under $300 a good alternative to the $600 price tag of the "Aria Classic" ??

[tricotec]

Originally Posted by Robi.1014

For those who have replaced the Aria Delux "noise maker"....

Is the Camping-World "Aqua Magic" at just under $300 a good alternative to the $600 price tag of the "Aria Classic" ??

Depends on what your priorities are. The Aqua Magic is a cheap, plastic toilet. We live in our RV full time, and a cheap toilet would ultimately affect our quality of life negatively, much as the "Devil Toilet" (my moniker for the Aria Deluxe) did. The Aria classic can be found for a bit less than $600. PPL has them as of this writing for $469. Keep in mind that internet prices often do not include shipping, so factor that in. We replaced our Deluxe ourselves and were very, very happy with it. I can tell you from bitter experience that nothing will wreck your quality of life faster than not being able to conveniently use the toilet.

Ultimately, the choice is yours. I'm a big (heavy) guy...a plastic toilet, frankly, is not up to the task. If you use your RV intermittently and are a small person or just don't have or want to spend the money because of other priorities, the Aqua Magic will do the job. I had an old Thetford plastic toilet in my old RV...was always afraid I would break it. (ultimately did)

[Robi.1014]

Bobby,
Great feedback. Was not aware of PPL source.

[tricotec]

Originally Posted by Robi.1014

Bobby,
Great feedback. Was not aware of PPL source.

PPL is a great source for stuff at good prices. I did have one bad experience with them when I bought a Dometic Penquin A/C. It was not packaged adequately and arrived damaged.

I have been amazed at what I've been able to find and obtain online. i recently found a cheap replacement for the little white cover to the remote A/C sensors...had one rot in the sun. Also found a source for the Southco drawer catches in the Monaco where the smaller piece on the drawer breaks...they are expensive if you buy both halves..I found a marine place that sold me just the smaller part that breaks the most.