Mine did same thing - was defective check valve (part of HWH bypass system) Crappy little plastic valve - guts held together by melting the plastic together - not made to last and it will clog up the line.
Mine was on the line coming out of the HWH and was right next to HWH. If you aren't in need of the bypass system for freezing weather just unscrew it, remove the broken guts and put it back in (just the hollow outer body). Did mine last year and works perfect - just can't bypass HWH when winterizing, but I keep my bays heated so no need. You'll get a bit better flow volume without the guts also.