Community Forums

LKANER · 07-18-2011, 07:19 PM

after "milking" 20 feet of 3" hose in 90 degree heat, I am ready for a portable Macerator System. trouble is, which one to get.. I went to the web an looked at the ones CW offers, and also ran accross an ad for the CLEAN DUMP RV Portable Macerator System. having no experience with these systems I need help on making the right investment. thanx Len

wa8yxm · 07-19-2011, 09:11 AM

I use a Flo-Jet, Very happy with it.. Sanicon makes a unit that is nearly identical, I suspect I'd be very happy with it.. Clean Dump, I don't know.

NOTE: You still have to empty the hose, it's just smaller diamater and longer run (My black hose is 50 feet) Personally.. I prefer the 3" when I can use it.. but the Macerator.. Very handy for those times when the 3" just won't cut the mustard.

Steve N Sal · 07-19-2011, 09:25 AM

Personally if you the 3" dump available at your site that's the way to go. You say you have to milk the hose? Is it just laying on the ground? If so get yourself a expandable tressel that expands from near ground level upward. This will let the hose drain properly as it will be in a gradual downward slope from the moho to the sewer drain. Now in our situation where we are at this time we have to use the macerator. Our dump outlet is 75' from the moho. We have a Sani-Con portable system and so far it works great. We also have a homemade unit that I made from a garbage disposal that is just great also. I was a little leary of the 12 volt macerator but as I've mentioned it has worked great so far and I hope it stays that way.

LKANER · 07-19-2011, 11:25 AM

thanx for the feed back. I have the tressel, and agree that most times it would be easier to use the 3". the problem right now is at home. with my trailer the drain was downstream. however now with the MH it is uphill and the MH connection is lower than the drain. that's why I am looking at the portable so I have the flexibility.

TXiceman · 07-19-2011, 06:49 PM

Check our sponsor, www.RV Upgrades and the Sanicon system.

Ken

Vegasdan · 07-19-2011, 07:58 PM

I have the portable Sanicon macerator. We have to use it about 4 months out of the year due to having to pump 100 ft. We had a problem with it after using it this past year (it was new a year ago April). The gaskets failed and allowed sewage water to enter the motor. I replaced the gaskets and the unit still works but I'm waiting for it to fail. These units are not well made. We prefer to use the simple 3" slinky if possible.

Dutch Star Don · 07-19-2011, 11:23 PM

Monaco use to offer the SaniCon system on most of its coaches. We have a built-in SaniCon unit. It has worked fine for 6 years. Its all we use. People say the 3" hose is faster and in the same sentence talk about using one of the support systems for the hose. All of that stuff are things that you have to take out, put away and clean. With the SaniCon system, you don't even need to completely drain the hose. Just but the cap back on.

Ed-Sommers · 07-20-2011, 08:27 AM

Check out the macerator's on ebay, they run around a hundred bucks.

They are not "systems" but a bare bones unit.

From my experience, if you have 24 volt's available from any source, that is the way to go.

Ed

mccsix · 07-20-2011, 09:13 AM

Took mine out of my last coach. Too much trouble. Takes too long to dump, maintenance, ect...nothing wrong with stinky slinky

TGMarrs · 08-02-2011, 10:04 PM

I purchased and installed a Sanicon, and now it is bypassed and I am using the regular hose.

The positive - it is very clean and easy & you don't get your hands dirty anymore.

The negative -

It takes 2-3 times longer to dump, during which time you have to stand with it so you can turn it off when it starts running dry.

It often pops the 20amp breaker several times during use, and sometimes overheats and shuts down for about 10 minutes.

The switch that came with mine broke and required replacement

Sometimes it stops in the middle of dumping the black tank and you have to use a screwdriver and turn the manual slot in the back to free up the blade inside and get it running again.

Twice it shut down on me in the middle of dumping the black tank. Nothing you can do but put the cap on and wait for it to cool down.

My final thought:
If you have to dump far away in a cleanout or uphill, get one. If you dump normally at dump stations and RV sites - I would consider it a waste of money. I purchased mine two months ago, and I really wanted it to work out, but now it is disconnected and the old 3 inch is back on. I don't plan to every try using it again.

Hikerdogs · 08-09-2011, 06:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LKANER

thanx for the feed back. I have the tressel, and agree that most times it would be easier to use the 3". the problem right now is at home. with my trailer the drain was downstream. however now with the MH it is uphill and the MH connection is lower than the drain. that's why I am looking at the portable so I have the flexibility.

WE use a mascerator at home for the same reasons. Rather than paying big bucks for the ones at Camping World we bought a Jabsco unit from West Marine. Like some others we bought the bare bones unit. Then went to the local RV store and picked up a couple fittings. Since it's quite a distance from where our RV is parked to the sewer outlet I had to get 75 feet of hose from McMaster Carr. With all costs included it probably isn't a lot cheaper than the commercial units, but it's customized for our application.

If you go the route of buying a unit from West Marine be sure to buy it on line or from the catalog. I tried to purchase the same unit from several of their brick and mortar stores. It was at least twice as much from the stores as it was online.

JimM68 · 08-11-2011, 07:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Diplomat Don

Monaco use to offer the SaniCon system on most of its coaches. We have a built-in SaniCon unit. It has worked fine for 6 years. Its all we use. People say the 3" hose is faster and in the same sentence talk about using one of the support systems for the hose. All of that stuff are things that you have to take out, put away and clean. With the SaniCon system, you don't even need to completely drain the hose. Just but the cap back on.

My Knight also has a builtin sanicon system.
And a tecma macerating toilet to go with it.

It doesn't smell, ever.
It isn't messy, ever.
It doesn't take all that long to dump, really.
You can still leave the gray valve open.
And no, it doesn't blow fuses, burn out switches, or jam up, ever.

Once was enough, I'm never going back.

TGMarrs · 08-13-2011, 04:28 PM

Well, that's 2 that have a totally opposite experience than me... Perhaps I should exchange mine for another one and try it again - perhaps I got a lemon?

JimM68 · 08-13-2011, 07:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TGMarrs

Well, that's 2 that have a totally opposite experience than me... Perhaps I should exchange mine for another one and try it again - perhaps I got a lemon?

I'd guess you might have an installation problem, the switch and relay and possibly power feed are not what they need to be.

Also, I think the techma potty has a lot to do with my positive experience. Thanks to that electric toilet, my black tank contains no "solids" at all.