The past two days I've been doing extensive and exhaustive (exhausting) testing. I mentioned about two weeks ago I was going to order 2 more SureCall antennas and try very short cable lengths and mount then on the back side of the AV box. Well, apparently I never completed the order process and they never came, which is a good thing. Now having placed two more orders I see why the final step was missed, not the most ideal checkout process at 3/5Gstore.com but so be it.
I spoke with a rep at 3/5GStore.com asking their opinion on the best LTE antenna as I wanted to do more testing. Happy with the SureCall's but what else was good. She recommended the Panorama antenna but the price was a bit of a put off. She pointed out antennas with 5db gains, long story short I ordered the
Panorama LGMM 5-in-1.
I also wanted to do testing with the SureCall on a ground plane so I designed
a concept and 3D printed it that could hold a 8x8 inch thin sheet of aluminum under the top mounting plate. I also designed and 3D printed
a mount to elevate the panorama antenna and give me a smaller footprint on a potentially curved mounting surface. Good thing, I needed it to fit it between my surecall wires and the defunct/unplugged WFR.
I first tested the surecall's as they were on both Verizon and AT&T, keep in mind I'm in a remote location. I took screenshots and notes of all of the numbers from speed tests to the cellular strength readings. I then moved the antennas to the ground plane mounts and noted a slight improvement. I'm going to leave the surecalls on the ground plane mounts for a while and get more testing.
I then finally got to testing the panorama antenna. Tons of cables with 16ft of each (5) wowza! I taped the antenna to the center of the roof right of my surecall wires and draped the wires to go through the driver's side window. I fired it up and wow, I actually got LTE-A on Verizon! Woohoo!!! Speeds were amazing. I then tested the WiFi and backed I'd say at least 100ft from the RV and the speed tests were still great. Around 100ft the wifi indicator on the iphone dropped a bar. NOTE: Not the best judge of distance, I think it was more like 200 ft but I'm not sure. Regardless, the wifi is powerful!
Okay, let's do it. Yesterday I struggled a bit with the getting the hole from the roof down to the AV cabinet over my driver's seat. I have two holes already from the WFR and the Weboost/Surecall so I wasn't too concerned with alignment. I drilled through the fiberglass cap and put a flashlight pointing up from the AV box side to help connect the dots. Well, they didn't quite connect so out came the endoscope and that didn't help but so much but I did see things in the roof cap I was a bit surprised to see, but all is good. A trip to Lowe's for a 3/4" long bit and time to drill for oil. Got through, no prize trips to Newmar, cables dropped through. I connect up and bummer, no LTE-A on Verizon this time. I secure the mount and dicor it, called it a night, it started raining.
The numbers were close to the surecall, nothing really earth shattering and I never got LTE-A again on Verizon. AT&T was the winner for where I am. I am satisfied with the antenna and believe it is slightly better than the SureCall and obviously gets WiFi on the roof at the same time.
Before I forget, the panorama says ground plane is not needed and if you did add one it has to be at least 20x20 inches. I emailed both 3/5Gstore.com and Panorama with my concern about the RV roof being fiberglass vs. metallic like most use cases for this antenna and both said clearly, no ground plane required.
In working on the wiring in the AV box what I noticed was the antenna has about 2-3 foot cable it comes with and someone added 16ft lengths. I was able to cut through the heat shrink and separate/remove the extension and it wasn't needed for where I'm mounting my pepwave (see attached). So I figured I'd see something amazing by having such a short cable. NO DIFFERENCE. I'm sorry, I do not believe the cable length is a factor in the discussions we've had with quality/low loss coax. From 2-3 ft compared to 16+ ft, the numbers did not reflect the change. But I don't want all the extra cable so this works out ideal, I'll cut down the WiFi coax once the correct SMA connectors come Wednesday and tidy up the install.
In today's final power up Verizon actually attached to Band 2 (1900 mhz) instead of the 700 mhz bands and had 20 MB/20 MB speeds instead of the barely 2 mb/s. It would be interesting to only allow the high mhz bands and see how Verizon handled that at this location.
The numbers show better for the Panorama and I'm sticking with it. Having the surecall's on the roof is why I decided to get the BR1 MINI today as I already have a MIMO setup ready for it.
Here are the stats:
Surecall:
Frequency Range: 698-960/1700-2700MHz
Antenna gain: 2-3dB at 698-960 MHz; 3-4dB at 1700-2700 MHz
Impedance: 50ohm
Panorama:
Frequency and gain:
Cable 1 & 2 (cellular):
2.3db at 698-960MHz
5db at 1700-2700MHz
Cable 3 & 4 (WiFi):
2db at 2.3-2.7GHz
2db at 4.9-6GHz
Cable 5 (GPS):
26db at 1575MHz
VSWR:
Cellular: < 2.5:1
WiFi: < 2:1
GPS: <2.0:1 ± 4MHz
A lot of testing, a lot of reading above, a lot of money, but I think it's a great system and far superior to weboost + WFR as we all know. I'll let you know how the two units work together when that gets setup later this week but it will take time to test and various locations to really see how things work out.