Quote:
Originally Posted by JVR
2006 Essex 4508
Each trip brings a new problem, where's the quality I have not found it, 40,000 miles, thousands of $'s and are we have fun yet?
Would I buy another Newmar?
JVR
|
JVR,
I'm new to motor homing so please take this with a grain of salt. However I'm not new to boats and there are some things that are very similar.
It's a motor home and stuff breaks.
I have found that one can pay $350k for a 39' motor yacht of $500 for the same size motor yacht. Example: a Mainship 34t was a $350k boat when it was in production in the 03-08 model years. A Nordhavn was a 40' boat in the same years and it was $450-600k. Both for all practical purposes were very similar. They both used the same engine, water heater, genset, bilge pumps, vac u flush heads etc. So why the difference. Well a lot was in the total build quality and design. Same mechanical parts but not used in the same way.
In boats there are several company's that built boats like the Mainship and there are a lot of them out there. Mainship, Hunter, Catilina but there are several like Nordhavn as well. Nordhavn, Selene, Swan. So does an Attwood water pump work better or longer in a Nordhavn than in a Mainship or Hunter, of course not, it is the same pump.
My point is, the cost is in the total build and design. I think the same holds true in this business. There are a lot of companies out there but if you look in the coaches you will see a lot of the same appliances, water pumps, A/C's, toilets, fixtures......... But the quality of the build is deeper. Every builder has their story as to why theirs is better for sure but I think Newmar runs up in the Nordhavn and Selene class not the Mainship, Hunter class.
Keep in mind that when a Trident sub like the Ohio returns from a six month deployment the crew stays on board until the squawks that appeared while out at sea are repaired before they turn the boat over to the new crew. My guess is that General Dynamics over charged the Navy way more for that boat than we pay for our MH. Yet they still break every day.
BTW there are even more expensive boat builder as in Marlow, Fleming to name just two but we have the same in MH's. Prevost is surely one.
Just my 2 cents.