You may need to use a very fine abrasive rubbing compound like this:
http://tinyurl.com/mz3rx8s
Just completed doing six Alcoa wheels that had suffered from road salt oxidation. They looked sort of white hazy before hand rubbing with the fine abrasive paste. I did it all by hand with a bunch of old towels. Wheels were returned to a pretty nice shine, but the next step was with Mother's Mag Wheel paste. Same technique ... all by hand. I do have the buffing "ball" but can't get down into the small grooves, so I found it just as easy to put on a pair blue gloves, and go at the task.
Hands are really tired tonight, but the wheels are back to showroom appearance.