I can't comment on the HR gasser's your looking at as I've never had one. Did have a 2008 Georgetown TSXL 378 gasser and loved it. We bought it used (2 yrs. old 15,000 miles) and had no major problems with it during the 8 years we had it. Mostly little stuff I could fix myself. We wanted to go to a DP though and bought a Holiday Rambler Navigator 36U this spring. It's had some minor issues, once again things I could deal with. The more serious issues were related to components that HR had nothing to do with per se, like the Atwood furnaces, Cummins diesel generator, some of the sound equipment, etc. Thus far we like the coach but the jury is still out on its overall build quality. But for what it's worth, we did like our Georgetowm......
Dave & Linda Haggbloom
2018 Holiday Rambler Navigator XE 36U
Toad - 2013 Ford C-Max