Yep... definitely plastic... as was the replacement. After seeing your post I looked online and don't see anything that would be a direct replacement in all metal construction (granted this wasn't an exhaustive search).
I was doing this work myself and the number one criteria for me was to minimize the time I had to spend under the motorhome so replacing with "bolt on replacement" was important to me. If it fails again in 20 years that will be someone else's problem
I'd be curious to know how many of these are plastic vs metal construction. Most that I stumbled across where plastic but that could be because I was looking for a direct replacement to a plastic unit.
I'm not trying to diminish the importance of your observation... just relating my thought process.