Quote:
Originally Posted by azloafer
What do you think? Are we foolhardy or not? Is there anyone else that never tows or are we alone? Joe & Mary Beth
|
This is a LONG response, but you are in the same place I was, and I wanted to show you my journey from being anti-toad, to can't live without it...
I grew up and my family always had a motorhome, and we never towed anything. When I got married, a camper was our first big purchase (OK, after the big screen TV).
Several motor homes later, I swore I would never tow a car behind us. My last coach was 35' and we vacationed all over with our three girls and never had a problem getting into and out of any place we wanted.
We were just like you!
When we decided on our "Great Adventure Tour", we purchased a 44' coach to live in for the year. I posted a question about towing a car just like you did - of course I did it in the toad section and got a resounding answer that I had to get a toad to full time. (what you were afraid of). I knew absolutely nothing about towing, costs, systems, time to hook up, etc. I was like you - if I needed a car I could rent one cheaper than paying insurance and toad setup costs.
My motor homes were 27', 30', 33', and 35' models. I could whip any of them around to anywhere I wanted. I ignored park road signs that said I needed to be 1-2 ft shorter and never had a problem. I was king of the road, master RV driver, unstoppable.
I disregarded the advise and we moved into the new motor coach and took our first big trip up through Montana and back home through Yellowstone. I found out a few things...
Although I am master of the universe driving a 35' coach, 9 more feet put me in my place. Initially I was fine. In Glacier NP we confidently drove into the camping area listed for max length 38' and found a great space. It did take a little bit of forward and backward to get there, but I did it. Then the kids wanted to go do stuff. I said everything within walking distance only because I was not about to spend another 20 minutes getting my coach out of and back into the camping space.
The next day, we took the free shuttle bus around the park. Disaster... lots of standing in line waiting to get around. Ate at an overpriced restaurant deep in the park because we were too hungry for the 1 hr line to get back on the shuttle back to the campgrounds (for a 10 minute trip)
If he had a car, we could have explored many more areas, but no worries, we had a good time and saw "enough".
We then drove through Yellowstone. I let my new found confidence in taking my 44' beast anywhere I wanted lead me into another campground listed for 38' max coaches. (same as in Glacier) After all, the feds must post the signs for RV drivers less skilled and qualified than me, right?
We again found a great spot, no problem, actually easier to get in and out than the last. As we made our way back out of the area to pay for the site, we got stuck. There was a switchback and I had a heck of a time going forward and backward to slowly inch my coach around the corner. We were there long enough for all the area campers to grab their chairs and sit outside to watch the show.
Needless to say, once free we didn't go back up there! We went all the way back to the north end where they had 60' long pull through spaces. Only problem here was that it was a 30 minute drive to see everything and then 30 min back to the camping spot. I had no learned my lesson, and I didn't even take the road that said max length 42'. We saw many roads and loops that we wanted to take that had length restrictions (some as short as 20').
On this trip I realized what the value of having a toad would be. Yes, it would cost more money to take one, but what about all the sights & activities we missed at Yellowstone because of not having one?
We still had a great trip - but it could have been better. But was it worth the expense and hassle of a toad?
I relented and purchased a 2005 Jeep Liberty diesel and a Blue Ox tow bar system. Our first trip with the toad was just 2.5 hours to Casper, WY to take the girls to a on-stage theater performance. I took the toad just for fun, because I could... and I wanted to test everything out and test the system before a really long trip.
We parked at Walmart and took the toad out shopping and going to the mall. It was fun and easy, and we returned to WalMart to sleep. The next morning we took the combination to a RV shop to fix a slide out problem. They fit us in, but it was a 4 hour fix. By pure luck, the Jeep was there and we got to go out sightseeing and ate lunch at a good restaurant instead of sitting in the coach waiting or being confined to walking distance from the shop.
I was completely sold on the toad with just this little weekend trip.
So in the end, you can live comfortable without a toad, and if you never have one, you won't know what you are missing. But kind of like a cell phone - you did fine without one, but now you can't imagine life without!